Goddards silver dip and milk spots

[Deus]

Tried IPA, acetone and finally a soak in some Goddards silver dip and nothing has removed milk spots. 
Are there any other chemical dips I can try? Don’t want to be rubbing each one with an eraser for hours. 

[stefffana]

1 hour ago, Deus said:

Tried IPA, acetone and finally a soak in some Goddards silver dip and nothing has removed milk spots. 
Are there any other chemical dips I can try? Don’t want to be rubbing each one with an eraser for hours. 

Unfortunately, the milk spots will not disappear with any solutions.

Goddards products are brilliant for tarnished silver objects, but can not remove the milk spots from affected coins.

[Petra]

Milk spots are a problem caused during manufacturing, so as previously mentioned, can not be removed like tarnish

[Deus]

28 minutes ago, Petra said:

Milk spots are a problem caused during manufacturing, so as previously mentioned, can not be removed like tarnish

Thought as much, well they will have to stay then. 

[Spyder]

If anyone has a most badly milk spotted 1 oz coin I will be willing to buy for a fair price. I have something I want to try and if it works will reveal. I do not  know if I am lucky, but my silver 1 oz don't seen to have been effected. I have eagles from 89 to KCIII. 

[BearlyHere]

The solution used to clean the planchet, if not properly rinsed off, is actually struck into the coin or round.  Sometimes it takes years to show.

[HillWalkerDundee]

Do I remember correctly that the solution used is Borax? If so, should we not try a Borax remover?

[Petra]

1 hour ago, HillWalkerDundee said:

Do I remember correctly that the solution used is Borax? If so, should we not try a Borax remover?

Various stuff may take off a bit of the milk spots, however, due to what causes them they don’t go away and will come back

[ArgentSmith]

I've successfully removed milk spots using an orbital sander 😉

[gji25]

The best thing imo is to make a coin ring from badly milked silver coins.

 

[HerefordBullyun]

1 minute ago, gji25 said:

The best thing imo is to make a coin ring from badly milked silver coins.

 

Awesome how did you manage that?

[DTL1982]

3 hours ago, gji25 said:

The best thing imo is to make a coin ring from badly milked silver coins.

 

That’s really cool. 

[gji25]

6 hours ago, HerefordBullyun said:

Awesome how did you manage that?

i did,nt make it. it was just a thought 👍

Edited June 29, 2023 by gji25
typo

[gji25]

9 hours ago, HerefordBullyun said:

Awesome how did you manage that?