Jump to content
  • The above Banner is a Sponsored Banner.

    Upgrade to Premium Membership to remove this Banner & All Google Ads. For full list of Premium Member benefits Click HERE.

  • Join The Silver Forum

    The Silver Forum is one of the largest and best loved silver and gold precious metals forums in the world, established since 2014. Join today for FREE! Browse the sponsor's topics (hidden to guests) for special deals and offers, check out the bargains in the members trade section and join in with our community reacting and commenting on topic posts. If you have any questions whatsoever about precious metals collecting and investing please join and start a topic and we will be here to help with our knowledge :) happy stacking/collecting. 21,000+ forum members and 1 million+ forum posts. For the latest up to date stats please see the stats in the right sidebar when browsing from desktop. Sign up for FREE to view the forum with reduced ads. 

Recommended Posts

Posted

Hello members

I was wondering, I have noticed that the 1925 SA mint Half Sovereign has a quite a low mintage, so is this one coin that was faked or did the the fakers not bother with the Half.

What would be the value of this coin or is just worth the same as others Half from that period.

Note, I have one, but it looks like someone decided to give it a polish.

Thanks in advance

Spyder

1925 SA h.jpg

1925 SA s.jpg

Never Chase and Never Regret 

Posted
1 hour ago, Spyder said:

Hello members

I was wondering, I have noticed that the 1925 SA mint Half Sovereign has a quite a low mintage, so is this one coin that was faked or did the the fakers not bother with the Half.

What would be the value of this coin or is just worth the same as others Half from that period.

Note, I have one, but it looks like someone decided to give it a polish.

Thanks in advance

Spyder

1925 SA h.jpg

1925 SA s.jpg

Your photos make it look like a fake.

It would help if they were in focus.

Cropping them would also help.

Perhaps you need:

https://www.chards.co.uk/blog/coin-photography-kit-taking-photos-the-chards-way/1046

😎

chards.png

Posted
1 hour ago, LawrenceChard said:

Your photos make it look like a fake.

It would help if they were in focus.

Cropping them would also help.

Perhaps you need:

https://www.chards.co.uk/blog/coin-photography-kit-taking-photos-the-chards-way/1046

😎

Thanks Lawrence for your reply.

All I got is my Samsung note phone. Sometimes I get a good photo and sometimes it comes out like this. Will try again and post a better photo.

Are you saying they did bother to fake half sovereigns during this time as it I would have thought, they would have concentrated on Sovereigns

Never Chase and Never Regret 

Posted
10 minutes ago, Spyder said:

Thanks Lawrence for your reply.

All I got is my Samsung note phone. Sometimes I get a good photo and sometimes it comes out like this. Will try again and post a better photo.

Are you saying they did bother to fake half sovereigns during this time as it I would have thought, they would have concentrated on Sovereigns

I wasn't saying they did bother to fake half sovereigns, but almost every coin ever made will have been faked.

And if not yet, then they will be on AliExpress next week.

😎

chards.png

Posted

Hi @Spyder I am poor at photography of coins (a little better at microscopy photography).

Others can give hints/ advice but the key ones from me are:

- Crop the image so the coin pic doesn’t have big borders

- Keep going until the coin is clear and crisp.

- I’m not joking but make sure you have cleaned the phone lens (I have fallen foul of this myself)

- Consider building a box out of cardboard that your phone sits on and you can control the lighting in.

Best

Dicker

Not my circus, not my monkeys

Posted
1 hour ago, dicker said:

Hi @Spyder I am poor at photography of coins (a little better at microscopy photography).

Others can give hints/ advice but the key ones from me are:

- Crop the image so the coin pic doesn’t have big borders

- Keep going until the coin is clear and crisp.

- I’m not joking but make sure you have cleaned the phone lens (I have fallen foul of this myself)

- Consider building a box out of cardboard that your phone sits on and you can control the lighting in.

Best

Dicker

Dicker, thanks for your advice. Sometimes I get a good photo, but with this coin it goes weird. Will give it another go when it's a sunny day. 

If I was selling plenty of coins I would invest a proper gear to help sell my coins. You are the third person telling me to crop the image. I will try and do some research about how to do that.

It seems everyone is more interested in the photo then trying to answer the question of what are the likely hood of this coin being a fake as the mintage was quite low for this year and is the coin worth just like any other half sovereign from this period.

Never Chase and Never Regret 

Posted

Why do you think this particular coin is fake?

I ask but I returned a 1925 SA half to a dealer this week as it just didn't sit right with me at all

Posted
1 hour ago, Spyder said:

seems everyone is more interested in the photo then trying to answer the question of what are the likely hood of this coin being a fake

Not sure what you looking for as an answer, people commented on the photo as that's the best way of judging if the coin you are talking about appears fake. If its a general quest, again people have asked why do you think this particular coin? There is a chance that all coins could be be fake, if some one has faked them. Even if not at the time of original releaseor any time in the last 100 years'ish.... are you hoping for a response of yes 100% some people have specifically faked a 1925 SA hald Sovereign?

Posted
23 minutes ago, Smiler999 said:

Why do you think this particular coin is fake?

I ask but I returned a 1925 SA half to a dealer this week as it just didn't sit right with me at all

It was reading your thread that got me thinking as I have the same year and from the same mint. What I did not understand was why would you have replaced it as it was such a low mintage year. If the dealer that sold you the coin said it was genuine. Was it verified that it was a fake?

 

Never Chase and Never Regret 

Posted
34 minutes ago, Spyder said:

It was reading your thread that got me thinking as I have the same year and from the same mint. What I did not understand was why would you have replaced it as it was such a low mintage year. If the dealer that sold you the coin said it was genuine. Was it verified that it was a fake?

 

Low mintage means nothing to me when I have doubts as to the authenticity of a coin

I simply sent it back and they sent another that was fine, I don't know if the test before or after they got it back, or scrapped it

Posted

I have downloaded the photo provided by OP and enhanced it a little.

It seems to me that the date (1925) is mis-aligned and the strike of the coin doesn't look right.

 I have also taken a photo of the same coin (with a bit of wear) from BBP for comparison.

The OP has commented in another thread that he used to be able to buy coins at spot from a coin dealer.

Judging from this example, I would be suspicious ! 

 

1761487908_1925SAdragon.jpg.2f743b31581ece411dd84ec0567c5029_edit_1037698131007991.thumb.jpg.b1c5e8e7c009858e6c0e0ab6dfb53e95.jpg

99b73ffe847cc11e41595a9d302ded19.thumb.jpg.4820e21db1fa8d8e93415cc346ec1c5f.jpg

Posted (edited)
7 hours ago, Spyder said:

It seems everyone is more interested in the photo then trying to answer the question of what are the likely hood of this coin being a fake as the mintage was quite low for this year and is the coin worth just like any other half sovereign from this period.

So this is because the photo is the only way that people on the forum can directly help.  You personally can measure coin, do a specific gravity test, feel it, weigh it, compare colour.

Clearly for us TSF folk to assess a coin picture it is key to have a super clear pic of the obv and rev. 

Are there counterfeits of this coin?  Absolutely yes, I have seen one personally.  

You will also find the following thread useful. We discussed an 1925 SA / not SA Half in 2017, and counterfeiting of Sovereigns. (I even have a book on this, which I purchased having seen a reference to it on @LawrenceChardwebsite.

The search function is very useful on TSF - a lot of ground has been covered previously which starts to help answer your questions. 

 

 

Edited by dicker
Typo

Not my circus, not my monkeys

Posted (edited)

The texture/ colour of the coin looks off, it doesn't look a proper matt finish, but that could be the photo. Have you weighed it? 

Edited by Jake0111
Posted (edited)
6 hours ago, Happypanda88 said:

I have downloaded the photo provided by OP and enhanced it.

The OP has commented in another thread that he used to be able to buy coins at spot from a coin dealer.

Judging from this example, I would be suspicious ! 

 

 

 

Thanks Happypanda88

The details on my coin do look slightly off on the dragon side,but are super sharp on the portrait side. Could be a fake.

This particular coin was purchased off ebay in Sept 2011 before I even knew my coin dealer. Just to let you know my dealer used to authenticate coins for The British Museum in the past so I have no worries about anything I bought from him.

5 hours ago, dicker said:

The search function is very useful on TSF - a lot of ground has been covered previously which starts to help answer your questions. 

 

 

Thanks Dicker

I found that article last night via a google search and then noticed that it was talked about in 2017 and it was noticed that there was no . after B or P and George had no left foot. At least my coin has a left foot.

45 minutes ago, Jake0111 said:

The texture/ colour of the coin looks off, it doesn't look a proper matt finish, but that could be the photo. Have you weighed it? 

Thanks Jake0111

The coins weighs spot on 3.99 grams and looks and sound the same as any other. Next time I am in Hatton Garden, It will get it tested on for metal content. 

Edited by Spyder

Never Chase and Never Regret 

Posted

Have not read most of the tread but try using a magnifying app and taking a screenshot, then crop. 

Posted

@Spyder its what puts me off buying on ebay, if i thought they was something wrong, it would take me to much time trying to authenticate it and would still doubt my self. 

Posted
15 minutes ago, Jake0111 said:

@Spyder its what puts me off buying on ebay, if i thought they was something wrong, it would take me to much time trying to authenticate it and would still doubt my self. 

I agree with you regarding ebay. I have not bought any gold coins since that year 2011. Only us ebay now for household odds and sods

 

26 minutes ago, Bigmarc said:

Have not read most of the tread but try using a magnifying app and taking a screenshot, then crop. 

Thanks, do you recommend any free app to do this. I have looked at cropping last night. still researching to see which is best to use

Never Chase and Never Regret 

Posted (edited)
1 hour ago, Spyder said:

Thanks, do you recommend any free app to do this. I have looked at cropping last night. still researching to see which is best to use

Just go to the app store and downloaded the highest rated one, most are free but with adds. I have a cheap £100 phone but this is the difference. 

IMG_20230114_125838196_HDR.thumb.jpg.e252385ade9944f6d6485454d8bae92c.jpg

2023-01-14-12-58-17-869.thumb.jpg.bb5bb4ea88db1cdb3e59e051d14f11fe.jpg

Genuine photos taken if the last 10 mins of the first coin I picked up to help a fellow silver forum member. (Don't try and knock me down on price). 😉

Edited by Bigmarc
Posted
7 minutes ago, Bigmarc said:

Just went to the app store and downloaded the highest rated one, most are free but with adds. I have a cheap £100 phone but this is the difference. 

IMG_20230114_125838196_HDR.thumb.jpg.e252385ade9944f6d6485454d8bae92c.jpg

2023-01-14-12-58-17-869.thumb.jpg.bb5bb4ea88db1cdb3e59e051d14f11fe.jpg

Genuine photos taken if the last 10 mins of the first coin I picked up to help a fellow silver forum member. (Don't try and knock me down on price). 😉

Thanks, that is a good photo

Never Chase and Never Regret 

Posted
10 hours ago, Happypanda88 said:

I have downloaded the photo provided by OP and enhanced it a little.

It seems to me that the date (1925) is mis-aligned and the strike of the coin doesn't look right.

 I have also taken a photo of the same coin (with a bit of wear) from BBP for comparison.

The OP has commented in another thread that he used to be able to buy coins at spot from a coin dealer.

Judging from this example, I would be suspicious ! 

 

1761487908_1925SAdragon.jpg.2f743b31581ece411dd84ec0567c5029_edit_1037698131007991.thumb.jpg.b1c5e8e7c009858e6c0e0ab6dfb53e95.jpg

99b73ffe847cc11e41595a9d302ded19.thumb.jpg.4820e21db1fa8d8e93415cc346ec1c5f.jpg

This is getting more interesting.

On the top photo, there is a strange raised lump near the top left, which would alert me to it being a probable fake, but...

even more interesting..

There are some features on the lower coin which I also don't like!

😎

chards.png

Posted (edited)

Here is the best picture I have taken using a Samsung Flip 4 belonging to my brother.

 

 

Lawrence, what have you noticed that raises your suspicion regarding bottom coin photo supplied Happypanda88?

1925 Sa V.jpg

Edited by Spyder

Never Chase and Never Regret 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...

Cookies & terms of service

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. By continuing to use this site you consent to the use of cookies and to our Privacy Policy & Terms of Use