Few years ago , I bought my first Morgan dollar, Now I’m questioning its authenticity

[Plajomzn]

So the said coin is a 1890 no mintmark , vf condition coin, Few days ago I decided to check its diameter and its 1mm off, it’s supposed to be 38.1, but mine is only 37mm, it’s also smaller compared to my real Eisenhower dollar which is supposed to be the same size. I tested the coin with the ping test and it sounds fine, it has the correct ping but little quite, I posted it on Reddit page few times too , and in the comments they thought it looked ok, the other thing is, I haven’t weighed it properly yet, because I only ordered coin scales few days ago and they haven’t arrived yet, but from as far as I tested it’s between 26-27grams on 1 gram precise scales. What do you think about it? 

[ChrisSilver]

I have removed the screenshot. Please can you add a photo of the actual coin, rather than a screenshot from Reddit  

[dicker]

Hi - assuming that you are not a one post wonder, can you post good quality photos of both sides of your Morgan?

Happy to help.

Dicker

[8ace]

Have you tried the ping test smartphone apps? I don't know how accurate they are, but combined with size, weight, magnet, SG check and a good visual inspection, it should give you a high probability of it being real. 

But as I'm no coin expert, take everything I say as opinion rather than fact. 

8ace

[stefffana]

@Plajomzn? You are not coming back?

 

 

[dicker]

I suspect this one was a “one pump chump”

[Muncle]

11 minutes ago, dicker said:

I suspect this one was a “one pump chump”

Seems like it🙄

[SidS]

On 22/10/2023 at 08:29, stefffana said:

@Plajomzn? You are not coming back?

 

 

The Wight Walkers have him - and now his watch has ended.