What is acceptable?

[StackinJack]

As I'm failrly new to stacking, I would like to know your opinion.
A few weeks back I ordered some 2oz Queens Beasts and they arrived pretty darn scratched.

As @BackyardBullion was telling in one of his video's, the Royal Mint has a reputation of pretty poor handling/packaging of the coins so a lot of them arrive with scratches and dents.
What kind of damage is acceptable? If any..
I returned the coins to the dealer requesting new ones, they accepted it and will return me some new ones this week.
Was I right to return them? And is it just the risk, or luck, to receive pristine ones?

And what if the dealer has a disclaimer that the coins can be scratched or have some damage to some extend.
So, what is acceptable?





Edit: typo

[Bullionbilly]

I would be livid if i got that ! Thats not acceptable

[StackerNoob]

Thats not from being in a tube of coins. Thats awful handling somewhere along the supply chain. Id be fuming too. My QBs ahve little dings and light scratches but nothing like that!

[MickD]

I have a couple of lions with light scratching from the tube but like @StackerNoob says above, that doesn't look like the kind of marks you get from being in a tube.