Grading Advice

[TheGoldSovereign]

Just wondering which coin people here would choose to keep as the best one, one clearly has more detail but has a larger scratch on the fields, how would they grade, the same maybe?

[augur]

The first one has less wear on the high points and the fields are cleaner

[augur]

NGC first one MS63-64

NGC and PCGS second one MS61-62

*) depending on the day form of the grader, you can extend the range by +/- one grade

[TheGoldSovereign]

I did keep the first one over the second, but I think exposure can blow out a lot of the surface marks, still I use the same settings it's just the first one had very shiny fields.

Thanks!